‹ All producers

Woodlawn Creamery

West Pawlet, Vermont · farming since 1831

Markets

The story

The Leach family has been dairy farming in West Pawlet, Vermont since 1831. Woodlawn Creamery is the newest chapter: instead of only shipping milk, the family now turns their own Holstein herd's milk into farmstead cheese right at the farm. When nearby Consider Bardwell Farm — a Vermont cheesemaking icon — wound down, Woodlawn picked up its signature recipes, and former Consider Bardwell cheesemaker Leslie Goff Tyminski now makes them for Woodlawn. So if a customer says "this tastes like Consider Bardwell's Pawlet" — that's because it is, continued.

What we sell

Customer FAQ

What does "farmstead" mean?

It means the cheese is made on the same farm where the animals are milked — nothing bought in. Woodlawn's cows are born, pastured, and milked on the family's own land, and the cheese is made right there.

Is this the old Consider Bardwell cheese?

Pawlet and Rupert are the Consider Bardwell recipes, made by the same cheesemaker who made them there, now with Woodlawn's own milk. Longtime fans should feel right at home.

Is it raw milk?

All the aged cheeses are raw milk, aged well past the 60-day mark that makes raw-milk cheese legal and safe. The fresh products (like Emerson) are pasteurized.

Which one melts?

Southwind — it's built like a raclette. Melt it over potatoes, into sandwiches, onto everything. Oxbow melts nicely too if they want smoke.

How should I store it?

Wrap in cheese paper or wax/parchment (not cling film directly on the paste), keep it in the warmest part of the fridge, and let it come to room temperature before eating — cold cheese hides half its flavor.

"Sorry, I'm lactose intolerant."

Actually, most cheeses aged at least 60 days — which is all of our aged cheeses — have almost no lactose at all! That lactose gets broken down pretty early in the cheesemaking process.

Still, cheese is a brick of fat and protein with no fiber. It might not flow right through you — not the easiest thing to digest a lot of.

Isn't raw milk illegal?

Raw milk dairy products are legal and safe if aged at least 60 days. At that point, the lower moisture level, higher acidity, and higher salt content will have killed off any unsafe pathogens that might have been in the milk. All the aged cheeses are raw; all the fresh products are pasteurized.

We make raw cheese in part because it saves us a step, but also because you can get some unique, unexpected, and often positive flavors from the wild bacteria that are hardier than most dangerous bacteria.

"But isn't raw milk, like, healthier and better?"

Milk comes out of a teat that's hanging just above the dirt and a stone's throw from a butthole. Farms are dirty places. Even though we're aging our cheeses, we're still abundantly careful and clean with every step of the process — testing bacterial activity, and discarding milk if it's not clean enough. Unless you know that's happening, you don't want to drink someone's raw milk.

Even still, raw milk is uniquely suited for growing the type of bacteria that have plenty of opportunities to get there. The negatives outweigh the positives. If they want good gut bacteria: eat aged raw-milk cheese, or just regular yogurt.

What's special about the maple syrup?

Even pure maple syrup sold in supermarkets takes shortcuts: they boil over a gas fire, and they use reverse osmosis to push extra water out of the sap so they don't have to boil it as long. That loses a lot of the minerality from the water, and the complexity.

This syrup is cooked over a wood fire — three logs a minute, for 13 hours straight.

"Whoa, this is aged in a cave? Like Batman?"

Curing predates refrigeration. Cheese and salami were traditionally aged in caves and basements because they were insulated and held a cooler temperature more easily. Then the bacteria that grew on the food started to grow in the caves, and those caves started to carry a unique flavor and aroma suited to the specific food aged there — like a seasoned cast-iron pan.

In modern cheese and salami making, we age them in temperature & humidity controlled rooms, but they still develop that unique, seasoned biome.

How do I increase my check averages to earn more in bonuses?

SELL BIGGER PIECES OF CHEESE

  1. Don't wait for them to ask for an amount. Pull out the cheese, hold the knife at about a 0.65 lb piece, and ask “How does this look?”
  2. Don't hesitate to go down until they say ‘when’, but always start from a heavy point. 75% of people will ask “How much is that?” Repeat after me: “Little over half a pound.”
  3. People look to you for clues on how to act. You are making it seem like that's the size of cheese most people buy, that's how much you eat in a week, etc.

SELL THEM MORE PIECES OF CHEESE

MENTION OR SAMPLE THE EMERSON, SYRUP AND SALAMI TO EVERYONE

Back when you had to speak to a human to order at McDonald's, they had workers ask everyone ordering just a burger “Do you want fries with that?”, and eventually “Do you want to make that a meal?” People didn't until they were asked to, because:

  1. they are trying to fit the norm,
  2. it's uncomfortable saying no, and
  3. they had to admit that they did want fries, they did want a drink, so yeah, what the heck.

Once they've picked their cheese(s), mention — or ideally give them a sample of — as many other things as possible. Ways of doing this:

You can get away with being a little jokey-pushy because you're not asking for a monthly donation — you're giving them delicious food to try, and you're selling as much as you can for the farm.

Got a question this page should answer?
Opens your mail app — goes to ph@tenbyten.biz so Peter can answer it and add it here.

Farm site: woodlawncreamery.com · Stumped by a question? Text Peter.